From
Colorectal Channel
Colorectal Quiz Episode 2: When to redo a PSARP
With Dr. Jason Frischer & Dr. Marc Levitt · hosted by Dr. Todd Ponsky
Chapter 1 of 5 · Case-Based Learning
Redo decisions
Introduction: The challenge of redo anorectoplasty decisions
Expert statements on this page
No expert statements were drawn from this page.
Host summaries · secondary, not cited in answers
Educational content from recorded physician discussions — not medical advice. Talk to your (or your child's) care team about your situation.
Podcast
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 2
Marc Levitt · 18 min · Published Jan 2021
Podcast
Anorectal Malformations Complications
Marc Levitt · 48 min · Published Feb 2016
Video
Rectal Prolapse Repair Following a Posterior Sagittal Anorectoplasty
4 min · Published Jan 2025
Video
How I Do It Levitt PSARP
7 min · Published Sep 2016
Video
Episode 19 - Interview with Dr Marc Levitt, Chief of Colorectal & Pelvic Reconstruction, Children‘s
Marc Levitt · 54 min · Published Oct 2021
Video
Rectovaginal Fistula
2 min · Published Jul 2023
Video
Validation of an anorectal malformation trainer - Can a high-fidelity model simulate real life?
1 min · Published Jun 2026
Video
Complications and Long-Term Outcomes of Patients With Cloacal Malformation After Bowel Neovagina...
1 min · Published Jun 2026
Video
Safety and utility of long-acting steroid injection for management of post-operative stricture...
1 min · Published Jun 2026
Video
Association Between Social Determinants of Health and Choice of Urinary Reconstruction in Children
1 min · Published Jun 2026
Video
The Perineal Body Preserving PSARP (PPP)
11 min · Published Jun 2026
Video
Update Course Rewind 2025: Hirschsprung + ARM: Rare but Real
1 min · Published May 2026
Podcast
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 47
Marc Levitt · 22 min · Published May 2025
Video
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 46 - Hirschsprung's Disease
Marc Levitt · 29 min · Published Apr 2025
Podcast
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 46
Marc Levitt · 29 min · Published Apr 2025
Video
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 44 - HD Frozen Section
Marc Levitt · 18 min · Published Feb 2025
Podcast
Colorectal Quiz: Episode 43
Marc Levitt · 23 min · Published Jan 2025
Video
Colorectal Quiz Episode 38: Transitional Care in Colorectal Surgery
25 min · Published Mar 2024
Podcast
Long-term obstetric and gynecologic care for patients with anorectal malformations
21 min · Published Sep 2026
Podcast
Post-pubertal gynecologic evaluation and management of patients with anorectal malformations
22 min · Published Sep 2026
Podcast
Pre-pubertal gynecologic evaluation and management of patients with anorectal malformations
23 min · Published Sep 2026
Podcast
Methods of gynecologic evaluation for patients with anorectal malformations
21 min · Published Sep 2026
Podcast
Gynecologic care in patients with anorectal malformations: A primer and call to action
18 min · Published Sep 2026
Podcast
Evaluation and Management of Postsurgical Patient With Hirschsprung Disease Neurogastroenterology & Motility Committee: Position Paper of North American Society of Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition (NASPGHAN)
17 min · Published Sep 2026
What the experts said
For anorectoplasty, if you don't get it perfect, you might not have the best outcomes, which separates it from other surgical procedures.
The original malformation in Case 1 was a prostatic fistula.
The patient in Case 1 has a tethered cord and a sacral ratio of 0.66.
The family doesn't really care how technically elegant is your analplasty. What they care about is whether that analplasty that you make is going to work and is the child going to be clean and in normal underwear.
The higher the malformation, the worse the prognosis.
A sacrum ratio of 0.7 or greater usually means normal or close to normal sphincters and good muscle tone, indicating that spine innervation of that area is probably good.
Patients can come with associated spinal anomaly, most commonly tethered cord, but the worst is a myelomeningocele, and those patients have much more trouble with continence.
Visual cues for identifying correct sphincter location include the anal dimple, a midline raised area where the sphincters are, the ellipse, color change, indentation or raised area, and appropriate perineal body length.
It's amazingly common to have a mislocated anus, either because the surgeon misses where the center is during laparoscopic pull-through or opens the PSARP incision first.
A key pitfall is opening the PSARP incision first; instead, mark the sphincters first, then open the PSARP so you don't get confused when placing the anoplasty in the correct location.
Case 2 patient was born with a vestibular fistula, has a normal spine and an excellent sacrum, indicating a much better prognosis for bowel control.
The electrical stimulator used is the same one that anesthesia uses for their train of four, with an inexpensive connection with little pins.
You have to tell your anesthesiologist not to give skeletal muscle relaxant because the stimulator is a little bit weaker than the traditional stimulator.
In higher malformations such as a bladder neck fistula in a boy, the sphincter complex isn't always where you think it's going to be and is sometimes more anterior than anticipated.
If you know the anatomy is off, you should do the redo, and there's an advantage to getting the anatomy right the younger the child is.
For a two-year-old with a mislocated anus or bad prolapse, offer a redo and let them live in diapers for a year or two with better anatomy, then see if they can successfully potty train.
Many patients present after the age of potty training because they're incontinent, and evaluation reveals the reason is they don't have the best operation—their anus isn't in the right place.
For patients presenting with incontinence after potty training age, do the redo and usually add a Malone at the same time so they can learn how to get control with their new anatomy before attempting voluntary bowel movements.
The process of learning control with new anatomy after redo and Malone may take 6 to 12 months.
For a patient with a mislocated anus that's 50% within the sphincter complex, three and a half years old and fecally incontinent, one approach is to redo them, do a Malone, get them perfectly clean mechanically, then see if they can develop bowel control.
An alternative approach for borderline cases is to let the child take their car out for a ride first and see how it works—if it drives well, stay with that anatomy; if not, then consider the redo.
If patients haven't declared their continence yet because they're not old enough to do so from a behavioral point of view, give them a chance—they may succeed.
A lot of surgeons agree that oftentimes your first shot might be your only shot to give this patient a good outcome and the right anatomy.
The vast majority of patients who get redos had mislocation, followed by stricture, then less common reasons including remnant of the original fistula (roof), rectal prolapse, and others.
Quality of life improved with a redo operation.
Patients had an improved ability to achieve continence after redo operations.
Patients who did not develop voluntary bowel movements after redo were still able to be clean with a bowel management program using enemas or antegrade via a Malone.
In the JPS study, 20% of patients with a poor sacrum or poor spine actually developed bowel control after their redo.
Patients with good potential (good sacrum and good spine) did extremely well after redo operations.
The average age of patients in the JPS study is about three and a half years, give or take.
