Biliary Atresia, Appendicitis, Intestinal Failure, and Anesthetic...
The START trial randomized 140 infants with biliary atresia to high-dose steroids (IV for 2 weeks, oral for 2 weeks, taper over 9 weeks) versus placebo within 72 hours of Kasai portoenterostomy.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position2:48 ↗
The primary outcome was serum total bilirubin <1.5 mg/dL with native liver at 6 months post-Kasai; the study was powered to detect a 25% absolute treatment difference.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position3:32 ↗
High-dose steroid therapy after Kasai did not result in a statistically significant treatment difference in bile drainage at 6 months: 58.6% in the steroid group versus 48.6% in placebo.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position4:01 ↗
Survival without liver transplant at 24 months was not statistically different: 58.7% for steroids versus 49.4% for placebo.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position4:39 ↗
Adverse events were common in both groups (near 80%), largely reflecting severe underlying liver dysfunction; steroid treatment was associated with earlier onset of serious adverse events.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position4:55 ↗
Dr. von Almen personally used steroids after Kasai in the past but has stopped based on the START trial results.
opinionDaniel von Allmen5:31 ↗
The authors of the START trial believe anything less than a 25% difference in bile drainage is not worth the potential early complications of steroids.
Host summaryDaniel von Allmen summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position7:11 ↗
Two proposed mechanisms for steroid benefit in biliary atresia: reducing ongoing inflammation to preserve ductules, and acting as a choleretic to maintain bile flow (analogous to diuresis after kidney transplant).
clinicalDaniel von Allmen9:09 ↗
The START trial specifically tested a 13-week course of high-dose steroids; the lack of benefit applies to that regimen.
clinicalDaniel von Allmen10:09 ↗
A Washington State registry study of clean-contaminated adult general surgery cases (60% colorectal, 34% bariatric) found no single skin antiseptic agent associated with lower SSI risk than any other.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position11:20 ↗
Isopropyl alcohol as part of the antiseptic mixture conferred no benefit: unadjusted SSI rate 4.5% without alcohol versus 4.6% with alcohol.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position13:49 ↗
The registry could not identify SSI diagnosed after discharge, likely underestimating the true SSI rate; a recent report showed 50% or more SSIs are diagnosed after discharge.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position14:20 ↗
Most SSIs occur 3–10 days after operation; average length of stay in the study was 6–7 days.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position14:48 ↗
Dr. Holcomb's institution switched to chlorhexidine with isopropyl alcohol (chloraprep) except for mucous membrane preps (e.g., circumcision).
clinicalWhit Holcomb16:30 ↗
Most pediatric surgery cases are clean (not clean-contaminated), so the Washington State study does not directly address pediatric practice.
opinionWhit Holcomb17:03 ↗
Chloraprep or similar agents dry faster than betadine/iodine preps, allowing cases to start sooner; this matters when doing 6–7 cases per day.
clinicalWhit Holcomb18:16 ↗
A pilot randomized trial in children aged 5–15 with non-perforated appendicitis (based on imaging) compared non-operative antibiotic treatment versus laparoscopic appendectomy; follow-up was one year.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position20:35 ↗
Of 225 children with appendicitis, 50 were randomized (26 to surgery, 24 to antibiotics); 77 families declined participation.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position22:42 ↗
In the antibiotic group, 2 of 24 underwent appendectomy during primary treatment, 1 had recurrent appendicitis at 9 months, and 6 more had appendectomy for recurrent pain or parental desire (none with histologic appendicitis)—total 9 of 24 (38% failure rate).
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position23:14 ↗
Median time to discharge was significantly shorter in the surgical group, but the antibiotic group had a stipulated 48-hour minimum hospitalization.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position24:35 ↗
Cost for the initial inpatient stay was significantly lower in the antibiotic group despite longer hospitalization, highlighting the cost of undergoing an operation.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position24:55 ↗
The pilot study demonstrates that a definitive randomized trial comparing antibiotics and laparoscopic appendectomy for non-perforated appendicitis is safe and feasible; a multi-center study is planned.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position25:20 ↗
Dr. Holcomb has not treated acute appendicitis non-operatively at his institution but knows of poor operative candidates treated successfully with antibiotics.
opinionWhit Holcomb26:33 ↗
Immunosuppressed cancer patients with typhlitis (not appendicitis but similar) are sometimes treated non-operatively, and most resolve with antibiotics.
clinicalWhit Holcomb27:00 ↗
The challenge will be identifying which population of appendicitis patients can be treated successfully non-operatively versus which should undergo early operation.
opinionWhit Holcomb27:22 ↗
Long-term follow-up is critical; even a 10-year follow-up leaves patients only 15–20 years old, with 40–50 years of life remaining at risk for recurrent appendicitis.
opinionWhit Holcomb27:52 ↗
Some parents in the pilot study wanted their child's appendix removed to avoid future worry, even after successful antibiotic treatment.
Host summaryWhit Holcomb summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position29:19 ↗
If appendectomy can be done as an outpatient same-day procedure, it may be difficult to argue for 1–2 days of antibiotics with uncertain long-term recurrence risk.
opinionWhit Holcomb29:45 ↗
A PIFCON multi-center cohort study of 272 children with intestinal failure (median follow-up 33 months) found enteral autonomy was achieved in 43%, 13% remained PN-dependent, and 43% died or underwent transplant.
Host summaryAaron Lipskar summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position31:31 ↗
Necrotizing enterocolitis as the underlying diagnosis, care at an intestinal rehab facility without a transplant center, and presence of an ileocecal valve were all statistically significantly associated with higher rates of enteral autonomy.
Host summaryAaron Lipskar summarizing the discussion — not the host's own clinical position32:58 ↗